The Missouri Department of Agriculture has banned the sale of health insurance plans that circumvent certain federal regulations, amid concerns from critics of the bill that consumers would be left without adequate protections or adequate coverage. It will be allowed.
The bill, which has already passed the Missouri House and is awaiting a committee hearing in the Senate, would allow health insurance plans that do not follow rules set by the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare.
The Farm Bureau would be allowed to deny coverage to people because of pre-existing conditions, for example, and to offer more limited benefits than allowed under federal law.
These practices also allow organizations to sell cheaper plans. Advocates say many farmers and other members of the Farm Bureau say: They don't buy insurance because they can't afford to buy a federally subsidized plan in the Affordable Care Act marketplace or they can't make too much money to qualify. Is not …
“What we're really trying to do here is provide these young farmers, potentially ranchers, and members of this organization with coverage options to better care for their families and loved ones. That's true,” said state Rep. Curtis Gregory, R-Marshall. the bill's sponsor said at a committee hearing in January.
The Missouri Farm Bureau is a nonprofit agricultural membership organization that partners with commercial companies to sell various types of insurance to its members. Anyone can join, but historically the group has been comprised primarily of people from rural areas.
“This is about allowing people to make their own choices.,” state Rep. Dean Van Schoiak, a Republican from Andrew, said during the House's consideration of the bill in March.
Missouri joins six other states (Tennessee, Iowa, Indiana, Kansas, Texas, and South Dakota) that have passed similar cuts to their Farm Bureau insurance plans. Several other state legislatures are considering similar bills this year.
The proposal faces opposition from some House Democrats, patient advocates and other insurers who are concerned about insufficient consumer protections and coverage and market disruption.
“We don't want people to get into unregulated health insurance and end up even worse off,” state Rep. Emily Weber, a Kansas City Democrat, said during the House debate.
Emily Kalmer, a lobbyist for the American Cancer Society's Cancer Action Network, said at a committee hearing in January that Missourians are being left “uninsured, paying too much money, or having their coverage denied.” They expressed concern that the consumer protections provided by law could be lacking.
The Farm Bureau will return to its pre-Obamacare, so-called medical underwriting practices, carefully evaluating applicants' medical histories and risks to decide whether to cover them and at what price.
“While we don't have experience with Farm Bureau plans in Missouri, we do have experience with medical underwriting in Missouri,” Kalmer said. “And that was scary for cancer patients in the past… Missouri used to allow these things, but it was scary for cancer patients. So it's not a 'what if'.” mosquito? The question is, “What is legally permissible here?''
Concerns about scope
The Farm Bureau maintains that even in the absence of regulation, members are accountable to their organizations, and that registrants in states with programs report high satisfaction rates.
Benjamin Sanders, a lobbyist for the Tennessee Farm Bureau Health Programs Office, testified before the committee in January that the organization has a 90% acceptance rate for applicants.
Tennessee enacted a version of the law in 1993 that exempted the Farm Bureau from regulation.
“There are conditions under which someone will be denied coverage…The best way to think about it is that if someone has an ongoing, fatal health condition, they will likely be denied coverage. ,” Sanders said.
After registration, the organization imposes a six-month waiting period before people with certain conditions can access the benefits. Mr Saunders said this was a “safety net” to ensure, for example, that people did not cancel their plans after signing up for expensive surgery.
Some Farm Bureau plans offer the 10 essential benefits required by the ACA, while others do not. Sanders said 75% of members choose a plan that includes all of these benefits.
In response to a question about whether pregnancy would be considered a pre-existing condition that would result in a six-month waiting period, Sanders said it depends on the plan.
“Generally speaking, pregnancy is considered a pre-existing condition…it depends on when you join and the length of your pregnancy,” he said, adding that those who try to participate when they are eight months pregnant are not eligible to participate, but it will take a few days. Ta. During pregnancy, most likely. Individual plans do not cover maternity care, but family plans do.
Sullivan and Republican state Rep. Danny Busick said opponents of the bill are offering a lot of “what ifs.”
Farm departments in other states are not required to follow data transparency requirements for regulated insurance companies. But the organization says internal statistics show high retention rates.
“Why do states that have this system have a 98% retention rate? If they hadn't reported on these things, people would be leaving the system left and right,” Busick said. he said.
“Just because it's not required by law doesn't mean we won't do it,” Busick said. “And I think that premise is what I have a problem with.”
The plan is not supervised by the state insurance department. Supporters say it's a contract and anyone dissatisfied with it could go to court. Opponents argued that it was not a viable option for many people.
“The current system is a regulated commodity,” said Kalmer, the American Cancer Society lobbyist. “You have the right to appeal to the Department of Insurance, and you can call the Consumer Protection Hotline to proceed, and the Department of Insurance will help you arbitrate your case.” “
There are still problems with the regulated market, Kalmar said, “but at least there's a process to make sure we're legally doing everything Congress has asked us to do here.”
State Rep. Brad Pollitt, R-Sedalia, said the Farm Bureau is “the answer to their members,” and if, for example, they start excluding people from the plan, “their membership is the answer to what's right for them.” I believe they will be held accountable for their actions,” he added. Because that's how they were raised. ”
Market trend
Other insurance companies oppose the bill, which would exempt only one group from federal rules, saying it would give Farm Bureau an advantage over its competitors.
Michael Henderson, lobbyist for the Missouri Insurance Coalition, called the proposal “unequal treatment in the marketplace.”
Henderson said the insurance company complies with the state's health mandate page.
“I've heard testimony that some of that coverage may be part of the plan,” Henderson said. “And Congressman Busick, you said we talk a lot about what-ifs. We also talk a lot about 'trust us.'”
The Farm Bureau plan is aimed at helping people who don't qualify for or can't afford Affordable Care Act subsidies.
Tim McBride, a health policy analyst and professor at Washington University in St. Louis, said he worries the Farm Bureau plan will attract healthier people and make benefits more limited. .
“The purpose of the ACA was to make sure there was no cherry picking by insurance companies,” McBride said. This means that some insurance companies are sucking up healthy people and raising premiums for other insurance companies.
He said research shows that people are “attracted by low premiums” but don't always look into the fine print, which is why the ACA sets rules about what is covered. He said this is one of the reasons.
“I certainly understand why people, especially farmers and their spouses and children, would want a low-premium plan,” he says. “But that's part of the purpose of the Affordable Care Act subsidies: to try to make plans more affordable.”
The federal government has expanded eligibility for subsidies in the Affordable Care Act market through next year.
In Tennessee, where Stat News reported in 2017, some experts believe participants in the Affordable Care Act market are sicker than other states due to the influence of drawing healthy people into Farm Bureau plans. It states that this could cause market problems such as a decline in corporate motivation. Participate and sell your project. The Agriculture Department denied any such influence.
Gregory estimated that about 11,475 Missouri Farm Bureau members do not have health insurance and said they would be eligible for the Farm Bureau plan. Others can also sign on, including members who currently have insurance but switch to a Farm Bureau plan, or those who join Farm Bureau to access coverage.
Sanders, of the Tennessee Farm Bureau Health Plan, said the amount isn't enough to make a difference in the market.
“But it does make a difference for members who take advantage of these plans,” he said.
Get the morning headlines delivered to your inbox
